Some cities and lawmakers are resisting crime-fighting tech owing to bias (偏见) and accuracy concerns. Police departments around the U.S. are asking citizens to trust them to use facial recognition software as a handy tool in their crime-fighting toolbox. But some lawmakers — and even some technology giants — are against it.
Take the western Massachusetts city of Springfield, where many residents are Latino or black. Springfield police say they have no plans to use facial recognition systems, but some City Council members are moving to block any future government use of the technology anyway.
At an October hearing on the subject, Springfield City Councilman, Orlando Ramos, defended the technology. "The facial recognition technology does not drop a net from the sky and put you to prison," he said, noting that it could serve as a useful investigative tool. However, he doesn't want to take any risks. "It would only lead to more racial discrimination." he said, citing studies that found higher error rates for facial recognition software used to identify women and people with darker skins.
Similar debates across the country are highlighting racial issues and concerns about the technology's accuracy. Axon, which supplies body-worn cameras nationwide, had already formed an artificial intelligence ethics board (伦理委员会)that concluded facial recognition technology isn't yet dependable enough to justify its use on police cameras. Axon Chief Executive Rick Smith said, "Even if facial recognition software was perfectly accurate, the ability to track people raises privacy concerns. "Do we want everybody who walks near a police officer to get their face identified and logged in a database?" he said.
Nevertheless, Todd Pastorini, general manager at biometric forensics (生物取证) company DataWorks Plus, said it's the "extremely effective" method of running images through photos to help identify a suspect. "Society and the public are going to get frustrated, if governments refuse to adopt a technology that keeps improving", he said. In his eyes, facial recognition hits are just one part of an investigation.
